This header image was generated using AI (Midjourney) for illustrative purposes. Used under commercial licence.
Marketing teams often tire of advertising campaigns before customers have even noticed them. In construction marketing, long buying cycles and fragmented audiences make creative consistency especially important. Research suggests that repetition, distinctive brand assets and sustained campaigns build brand recognition and memory more effectively than constantly changing creative.
By the time a campaign launches, the people responsible for it are often thoroughly sick of the sight of it.
They’ve sat through the briefing, debated the strategy and reviewed every creative route. They’ve discussed individual words, watched every edit and seen the finished work in presentations, media plans and internal launch materials.
Then it goes live and, a few weeks later, somebody asks ‘what’s next?’
The customer, meanwhile, may not have noticed it once.
Last year’s Horizon survey found that 20% of construction marketers intended to run more than ten campaigns during 2026 – that’s almost a new campaign every month. That is a lot of new creative competing for attention, budget and memory in a market that may encounter each campaign only occasionally.
The people closest to a campaign experience it completely differently from the people it is intended to reach. Without the proper distance and data, we can often mistake our own familiarity for the audience’s, grow bored of the work, and start changing things just as they might be beginning to work.
Put another way, marketing teams become bored because they are paying attention, while customers haven’t become bored because, for the most part, they aren’t paying attention.
Contents
We are paying far more attention than they are
This isn’t intended as negativity, or as an insult, although it may be an uncomfortable reminder to marketers. People do not care about our campaigns anything like as much as we do.
I’d argue that the discrepancy is particularly pronounced in construction. Some people might specify, purchase or recommend a particular type of product once every few years (think design software, machinery etc). Others make hundreds of specification decisions across multiple product categories and have little reason to devote much thought to any individual brand.
Yet the marketing team and its chosen agency have been immersed in the work for months. By launch day, internal familiarity can feel like market saturation, when in reality it’s anything but.
That false familiarity creates a powerful temptation to refresh the message, replace the visual language or commission an entirely new campaign. To everybody else, the brand may simply have changed again before they had a chance to recognise it.
Familiarity does some useful work
In 1968, social psychologist Robert Zajonc published Attitudinal Effects of Mere Exposure, proposing that repeated exposure to something can improve our attitude towards it, even when the exposure gives us no new information.
This became known as the ‘mere exposure effect’. Familiar things become easier to recognise and process. They can feel safer, less mentally demanding and, within reason, more likeable.
That qualification is crucial. Repetition cannot transform poor, irritating or badly targeted creative into good advertising. Later research suggests an inverted-U relationship: familiarity helps up to a point, after which its benefits can level off or decline.
It does, however, help explain why novelty is not always the virtue marketers assume it to be. Each time a brand discards an established idea, phrase, character or visual asset, it may also discard some of the familiarity it has paid to create.
We like to believe people carefully consider our messages. Much of the time, the more realistic ambition is to become easy to recognise, process and retrieve from memory when it matters.
What advertising actually has to do
Les Binet has a characteristically useful way of describing how advertising works.
In ‘How Not to Plan’, co-authored with Sarah Carter, Binet sets out a simple model. Advertising supports sales and margins by slightly increasing the chance that people will choose your brand: making it easy to think of and buy, while creating positive feelings and associations.
The word ‘slightly’ is doing quite a lot of work there.
Most advertising does not cause somebody to drop everything, find the nearest merchant and buy a pallet of insulation. Nor does it need the audience to study or consciously admire every execution.
As Daniel Kahneman’s work helped us understand, much of our thinking is fast, intuitive and requires little conscious effort. Advertising’s job is often more modest: help the brand come to mind at an appropriate moment and leave sufficiently positive associations when it does.
Sarah Carter has put the point more bluntly: ‘Consumers don’t give a shit.’ They are not waiting for our next campaign. Most of the time, they are not thinking about our category at all.
It’s this lack of thought that makes consistency so valuable in branding and communications. Repeated, recognisable signals give a brand more opportunities to establish itself in memory. If we keep replacing those signals, every new campaign has to do more of that work again.
Good advertising wears in
System1 tested the wear-out theory using its database of 50,000 advertisements, including work assessed long after its original launch, and found that older advertisements did not perform materially worse than newer ones.
It also retested the same 50 UK and 50 US advertisements between January 2020 and October 2022, through the pandemic, lockdowns and worsening economic conditions. The correlation between the original and final scores was still 0.9.
Good advertisements generally remained good. Some improved over time, particularly those with recurring characters, slogans or other recognisable devices. Weak advertisements did not become strong through repetition.
The most uncomfortable finding concerned what marketers did with that creative. In the US, five-star work remained in market 25% longer than one-star work. If you have invested in effective creative, you should be able to enjoy the fruits of that labour.
In the UK, sadly, the relationship was reversed. Five-star advertisements ran for an average of 71 days, while one-star advertisements were given 95 days. British marketers were retiring their strongest work sooner and giving weaker work longer to perform.
Seasonal campaigns, particularly Christmas advertising, affect the UK figures. Wear-out can occur, while excessive frequency and poorly adapted digital advertising can create irritation.
Kantar’s analysis of thousands of tracked advertisements found that genuine deterioration in creative quality was rare. Repeated exposure did not necessarily make an advertisement more enjoyable, but it did build branded memorability and predisposition.
It’s important to be clear about what wear-in means. It does not necessarily mean loving an advertisement a little more every time you see it. It can mean becoming quicker to recognise it, more likely to connect it with the right brand and more able to retrieve that brand later.
Consistency is bigger than running the same ad forever
None of this means putting the same execution into market indefinitely and refusing to respond to evidence. Consistency is not an excuse for laziness, and longevity should not be confused with quality.
The better objective is continuity: protecting the elements that help people recognise the brand while finding new and interesting ways to use them. In Ehrenberg-Bass terms, the objective is to build distinctive assets and use them consistently enough to strengthen mental availability.
That might include a consistent positioning, creative idea, character, scenario, phrase, soundtrack, tone of voice or visual language. System1 calls the most powerful recurring elements ‘fluent devices’. They give each new execution somewhere familiar to begin.
Its recent Compound Creativity research examined more than 4,000 UK television advertisements and matched them with 80 brands in the IPA Effectiveness Databank. A brand with an average campaign life of 713 days achieved a 15% annual improvement in ad-brand recognition.
The most consistent brands produced substantially more very large brand and business effects than the least consistent. The benefit was limited in the first year and accumulated thereafter.
Creative consistency should provide a platform for invention. Specsavers continually finds new ways to dramatise poor eyesight without abandoning ‘Should’ve gone to Specsavers’. Yorkshire Tea tells different stories while remaining recognisably Yorkshire Tea. The audience gets something new without having to relearn who is speaking.
The challenge is knowing which parts of the work should evolve and which parts have earned the right to stay.
Construction gives creative even less chance
Construction businesses are especially vulnerable to cutting the process short.
We often market into categories with long replacement cycles, complicated decision-making units and several routes to market. The person who notices the campaign may not be the person who specifies, purchases, installs or lives with the product.
Media budgets are frequently modest relative to the number of audiences involved. A campaign may be divided among trade media, paid social, merchant activity, exhibitions, sales materials, specification tools and content, reducing the frequency experienced by any one person.
Even professional decision-makers have limited attention. An architect, contractor or merchant may deal with hundreds of brands and product categories alongside regulation, programme pressures, cost and risk. Our campaign competes with all of that, as well as with direct competitors.
Familiarity is not evidence of competence or product suitability, particularly in a safety-critical industry. However, a brand and its claims must first be noticed, recognised and retrieved before they can be properly evaluated. Consistency helps it reach that point.
Internally, though, the work is everywhere. It appears in every sales meeting, board report, desktop background and trade-show planning session. Colleagues understandably feel that they have seen it a lot.
Then the annual planning cycle arrives. A product needs launching, a new marketing director wants to make a mark or the agency is asked for something fresh. Activity follows launches, exhibitions and budget years; customer memory follows no such timetable.
The pressure to feed more channels with more content makes the problem worse. Brands can produce a constant stream of superficially new assets while repeatedly changing the signals that would have helped those assets accumulate value.
In an industry where many buyers spend very little time actively considering any individual category, that is a costly habit. We may be removing the signposts just as customers are learning to recognise them.
If you need a stat to help to land the point with your internal teams, try this; the B2B Institute (working with research firm Newton X, and Bain & Co) found that in 81% of B2B buying situations, everyone involved in the process was familiar with the selected brand at the start of the consideration process.
Put simply, unless you can stick in memory you won’t get purchased – and you won’t be remembered if your means of building memory are too fleeting.
Before you kill the campaign
There are perfectly good reasons to change creative. The strategy may be wrong. The work may be weak, poorly branded or no longer appropriate. The market, product or organisation may have changed materially.
Boredom is not one of them.
Before replacing a campaign, I’d ask five questions:
1. Is there evidence that its effectiveness has declined, or are the people closest to it simply tired of seeing it?
2. Has enough of the market encountered it with sufficient frequency to recognise and remember it?
3. Can customers correctly connect the work to the brand?
4. Which elements are building memory and should be protected, even if individual executions change?
5. What commercial or customer problem will the new campaign solve that the existing one cannot?
Those questions require research, tracking and judgement. If you cannot answer them, the absence of evidence is not evidence that the campaign has stopped working.
That may be less exciting than a new creative platform, but it is considerably cheaper than continually rebuilding memory from scratch.
Marketing teams will nearly always tire of campaigns before customers do. We see too much of the work and they see too little.
The answer is not to suppress creativity or run weak advertising into the ground. It is to recognise that effective advertising needs time to become familiar, distinctive and easy to retrieve.
Your team may be bored. Your customers may only just be beginning to notice.
Still have questions? We’ve answered some common ones below:
Frequently asked questions
There is no universal ideal campaign length. It depends on audience reach, frequency, buying cycles and performance. Campaigns should be evaluated against evidence of effectiveness rather than internal fatigue or arbitrary planning deadlines.
Yes. Repeated exposure to consistent creative elements can strengthen brand recognition and recall. This is particularly valuable in B2B marketing, where customers may only consider a purchase occasionally.
Advertising wear-out occurs when repeated exposure reduces an advertisement’s effectiveness. However, research suggests that strong creative often maintains its effectiveness over time, while repetition can improve brand memorability.
Construction marketing involves long buying cycles, multiple decision-makers and fragmented audiences. Consistent messaging and distinctive brand assets help businesses remain recognisable when customers eventually enter the buying process.
A campaign should be refreshed when evidence shows declining effectiveness, changing customer needs or outdated messaging. Updating individual executions while retaining recognisable brand assets can preserve familiarity without sacrificing creativity.










